Broken and leaking heat exchangers are responsible for about 1,500 deaths per year in the united states, and many more people are poisoned by exposure to toxic gasses that go unfiltered by defective heat exchangers. Dec 22, 2008 ive read from several pages that a furnace with a cracked heat exchange should be shut down and replaced immediately. It has been taken care of well over its 30 years of service. A furnace heat exchanger works by literally exchanging or transferring the heat created in the combustion chamber to the exterior of the unit, where it is then blown through the ductwork throughout the house. However, the repairman stated that there was a crack in the combustion chamber, and the furnace needed to be replaced. If the heat exchanger develops cracks, the metal will get discolored with the soot that builds up on it. Dec 06, 2011 heres the deal if another company says the heat exchanger in your furnace is cracked, rusted, or broken in any way, care heating and cooling will come to your house at no charge to confirm the diagnosis. If the heat exchanger is cracked, then it is nothing to mess around with and either the furnace or the heat exchanger need to be replaced right away. The heat exchanger is the heart of your gas furnace, can cost a lot of money to repair and may go totally undetected until the homeowner performs routine maintenance on the unit. I wrote a blog post many years ago discussing that topic, and the gist of my blog post was the same as whats stated on the comyths web site. The secondary heat exchanger is designed to extract the maximum remaining heat from the fuel source, resulting in a normal condensation reaction. This one takes apart the ruudrheem heat exchanger to inspect the cracks.
That you can test for carbon monoxide at the register if there is a crack in the heat exchanger. Any changes to air pressure inside the heat exchanger or air patterns can have large effect how clean the flame burns. The fluids may be separated by a solid wall to prevent mixing or they may be in direct contact. A heat exchanger is a system used to transfer heat between two or more fluids. Find them too often, and your company could get a rep for using scare tactics. A smoke bomb test a smoke generator is placed in the heat exchanger, then the outside of the heat exchanger is visually accessed to watch for smoke passing through the crack. A cracked heat exchanger is a serious failure in your gasfired furnace. Heat exchangers are used in both cooling and heating processes. During the furnace heating cycle the combustion gas will travel through the heat exchanger and exhaust out of the furnace.
Dec 02, 2015 the other half turn out to be unethical tactics to sell new furnaces. But, theres no chance that air from inside the exchanger can ever make its way into the homes indoor air stream. Its not unlike a doctor telling you about the c word. Will a cracked heat exchanger leak carbon monoxide. The air may blow the main burner flame around or cause it to roll out of the front of the heat exchanger. Heat exchangers are made from metals which tend to expand and contract as the hvac heats and cools. And if someone is checking carbon monoxide in your duct work to determine a bad heat exchanger, i would be very concerned. The heat exchanger in a furnace separates the combustion process from your breathing air. Here, we share a few reasons why heat exchangers crack and how to prevent them. Unless you are one of the top 3% of people who have all the money, replacing the furnace is going to hurt the pocket book if you have not planed for it, but it has to be done.
Signs and symptoms of a cracked gas furnace heat exchanger. This effect will get worst as the furnace heats up from expansion and the crack gets bigger. A pencil size hole or hairline crack in a heat exchanger does not, in my opinion, justify shutting off the heat on someone in the middle of winter. How to determine if your furnace combustion chamber is cracked. When a heat exchanger becomes damaged and the combustion fumes and. We have had two issues with the unit and have been in the townhouse for a little under two years. So far this season, we have run at least fifteen second opinions on cracked heat exchangers and we have yet to confirm a single crack.
The oil company we deal with has told us that the chamber is no longer made and a wet pack will be needed to seal the crack that has developed on the right. Buy products such as daisy youth line 1938 red ryder air rifle, daisy youth blue air bb gun. Electrical and metallic odors generally stem from excessive heat within your furnace. Combustion gases leaking from a cracked heat exchanger can cause frequent headaches as well as flulike symptoms.
A co detector can indicate a heat exchanger is cracked or perforated only if all of the following conditions occur simultaneously. Dangerous cracked heat exchangers in furnaces everyone wants heat when old man winter arrives in the fall. Some heat exchangers are a hybrid such as steel with an aluminized coating. Furnace heat exchangers what is a heat exchanger in a furnace. However, using a combustion analyzer to test for cracks in a heat exchanger offers.
Danger of a furnace with a cracked heat exchanger servicemax. Over time, the heat exchanger can crack or separate, allowing carbon monoxide to enter the house. If you have an iron heat exchanger, then you need to find an iron repair liquid, which uses chemical reactions to seal holes in iron. This video is part of the heating and cooling series of. For a good example of a hazardous heat exchanger, check out the photo below showing a large rust hole in the heat exchanger of this highefficiency furnace that was only ten years old. I have a gas furnace that is approximately 11 years old.
Proper diagnosis of a failed or cracked heat exchanger. The heat exchanger contains the gas combustion chamber. Advice for replacementrepair of an hvac with a cracked heat. Weve met with lots of homeowners looking for a second opinion about a supposedly cracked heat exchanger. Removal of the fan assembly indicates a dirty heat exchanger and blower wheel. Read our blog to learn what to do if this happens to you. This is a total waste of time in most cases because the blower motor of a residential furnace is positive and the combustion side of the heat exchanger is a negative, the much more powerful. About a week ago, the unit began blowing only cold air. A broken heat exchanger increases the risk of fire and can distribute carbon monoxide fumes throughout your home.
The most common mishap in a heat exchanger is a crack, which happens from the metal changing temperatures. Ask the contractor if he has a combustion analyzer in order to do this test. Corrosion because of reaction between the combustion gas and the metal often because of improper venting can also weaken the metal to the point where cracks form. In the case of a forced air furnace, it is two different air streams.
It is the common reason as to why most heat exchangers crack. A cracked heat exchanger is typically noticed when the homeowner reports not having heat or when the. A gas furnaces heat exchanger is the furnace component that actually heats the air. I noticed the other day the my how water boiler had flames dancing around underneath the heat exchanger. I dont see how it could end up causing flame rollout here. Over time, cracks can form, allowing toxic gases to escape.
The american gas association allows two options after discovering a cracked heat exchanger. Older furnaces can develop major issues, such as a cracked heat exchanger. So the 2nd 3rd heat exchangers usually produce a lot more condensation than the first heat exchanger. The heat exchanger of a furnace separates the combustion side from the air side, keeping the. The extra air will cause the oxygen reading to change notably. I just bought myself a testo 320 combustion analyzer. Less energy needed to cool or heat a building means a more energyefficient hvac system. Gas furnace heat exchanger clogged problem what it looks like and burn spots. This component cycles heat out of the combustion chamber and into the plenum. How do you guys diagnose cracked or bad heat exchangers. As the supply air is pushed by the blower across the heat exchanger tubes, the heat transfers away from the heat exchanger to the. Carrierbryant has a very specific procedure to test the heat exchanger on their 90% furnaces. For residents of georgia, having an hvac, or heating, ventilation and air conditioning system, is imperative.
Guide to furnace heat exchanger inspection, testing, leaks how to inspect and test furnace heat exchangers for leaks photographs show clues indicating leaky, dangerous furnace heat exchangers furnace heat exchanger leak testing, a complete list of methods used to find or test for leaks in a furnace heat exchange what is the allowable amount of gas fired heat exchanger leakage. I am being told by a furnace repair guy who i had come in to perform annual maintenance that i have cracks in the heat exchanger and that he needs to turn off my gas right now by law. Remove it from the furnace, and examine it in the light. Instead, the combustion gas enters the heat exchanger, a metal clamshaped chamber. Cost to repair furnace estimates and prices at fixr. Gas furnace heat exchanger clogged problem what it looks. The heat exchanger absorbs energy from the burner flame and transfers it to airflow in the furnace plenum.
As for what your home waranty will cover, i do not know the terms, but it is useually tough to get replacement heat exchangers for older furnaces, so you may have to replace the whole furnace. Mar 19, 2007 a smoke bomb test a smoke generator is placed in the heat exchanger, then the outside of the heat exchanger is visually accessed to watch for smoke passing through the crack. In many cases our technicians find that the other companys diagnosis is wrong and the heat exchanger is perfectly fine. The unit is probably 30 years old and it seemed to be working fine. The cause of cracked heat exchangers avoid this common scam.
These furnaces were installed in the early 90s and virtually all of their heat exchangers failed. This separates dangerous combustion gases produced by the burner from the heated air that circulates through your home. This video is part of the heating and cooling series of training. When the temperature falls all we have to do is go to the thermostat and turn the heat on. Now that you have fixed the heat exchanger, replace it in the furnace. At its simplest level, a heat exchanger allows for the exchange of heat between two fluids without the fluids mixing. The american gas association has even put this in writing they say any visible crack or hole is reason for requiring replacement of the heat exchanger or furnace. Some people choose to live in denial of the seriousness of a cracked heat exchanger. Can you repair a cracked heat exchanger on a gas furnace. The heat exchanger is always under negative pressure, so you would need a massive hole in the heat exchanger to get any co in the duct work. May 12, 2000 miss a cracked heat exchanger and you put the homeowners at risk. The heat exchanger on a furnace is the section that keeps the combustion chamber and the breathing air separate 3. Hvac businesses in minnesota lock out furnaces when cracked heat exchangers are found. This is because air is leaking through the crack in the heat exchanger into the combustion chamber.
The combustion chamber houses the burner, which produces toxic gases. A co detector cannot tell you if a heat exchanger is good. If someone informs you that your heat exchanger is cracked, call the tedder company, and one of our specially trained technicians will immediately assess your furnaces situation. Combustion pollutants, such as carbon monoxide, nitrogen dioxide and sulfur dioxide, can cause eye and nose irritation, disorientation, sleepiness and nausea. This trips a safety switch and shuts down the furnace. Cracks in your furnaces combustion chamber can be deadly. If a crack has developed, air from the house will be forced into the combustion chamber when the blower turns on, causing some visible disturbance of the flame, he says. The cause can be anything from tilted burners to cracks in the heat exchange itself. We give free second opinions on cracked heat exchangers. Because the metal of the heat exchanger expands and then contracts as it heats and cools, the stress may eventually cause a crack to form on the exchanger. Simple furnace heat exchanger test hvac learning solutions. Leaking navien cr240 heat exchanger replace or repair.
You know its serious and you know you need to do something about it. This video is about the your heat exchanger is cracked so your furnace must be replaced scam. If the heat exchanger is cracked, air is forced into the combustionchamber where. I cant understand why a heat exchanger being cracked would cause flame rollout though. The chamber becomes corroded from the inside, possibly due to a reaction from acidic condensation on the polypropylene coating. Have you heard this one recently, you have a cracked heat exchanger and your furnace has to be replaced, today. Heat exchanger failure diagnosis, goodman gmp model youtube. The heat exchanger is manufactured from thin metal, and will be mild carbon steel or stainless steel depending on the type of furnace. From what ive been told and read, it could mean that my heat exchanger is cracked. You either have an induced draft pulling air up over the heat exchanger to let the air vent out the flue of a forced draft that pushes air over the heat exchangers out the vent. Bob not only knows why cracks in heat exchangers sometimes develop, but he also knows what homeowners should do when this problem occurs as well as how regular maintenance can help prevent. A heat exchanger is made of thin metal, and as it heats up from the combustion of the furnace, it transfers the heat to the air being distributed through the house by the blower 3. This would imply an opening in heat exchanger allowing household air to blend with heat chamber indicating a hole or crack.
Dec 22, 2010 will a cracked heat exchanger leak carbon monoxide. If theres a crack in this component, the gases being burned off, such as carbon monoxide, sulfur dioxide, and nitrous oxide, could leak into your home, causing illness or, in extreme cases, death. It is a system which controls the primary climate inside your house or home enabling you to stay comfortable and healthy. Furnace heatexchanger crack signs your furnace has one. A damaged heat exchanger in a gas furnace is potentially dangerous to a homes occupants and should not be ignored. It continued to blow cold air, even when i turned it off. The your heat exchanger is cracked so your furnace must be. Convection heat transfer, thermal conduction, thermal radiation.
The flame generates enough co lack of oxygen, excess fuel, high temperature. As seen in figure 1, the typical heat exchanger comprises several metal tubes wrapped in a serpentine fashion that are connected on one end with the systems burners and combustion chamber, and on the other end to a vent or exhaust flue. Enough exhaust gases are emitted from the heat exchanger crack or. If this test fails, the heat exchanger should be replaced under the 20 year warranty. The heat exchanger is a key part of the furnace and is responsible for the actual heating of air. The furnace heat exchanger is the one of the main components inside the gas furnace and its used to transfer the heat from the gas burner to the warm air thats blown into your home. Heat exchange namibia 2 brahman street, northern industrial, windhoek.
If your heat exchanger is cracked, it can be dangerous for you and your family. He explained that even though the heat exchanger was under warranty and could be replaced that it would be better to go with a new unit because the cost of labor to replace the hear exchanger would make it not worth it. The cracks will allow that deposit through, making the heat exchanger appear sooty, as discussed in the. It is important that the heat exchanger is taken care of as hazards can build from a faulty exchanger. Basically, the heat exchanger is where the furnace heats the air. This video is part of the heating and cooling series of training videos made to accompany my websites. Were you recently told that your furnace heat exchanger is cracked and needs to be replaced. Located in the center of the furnace, it is where fire, gas and heat connect. In a typical season, our nate certified furnace technicians confirm less than 10% of these as real cracks. A furnaces heat exchanger is a set of tubes or coils that are looped repeatedly through the air flow inside your furnace for the purpose of heating air. The heat exchanger, or heater core, is the most important part of your furnace, as it is hub of all combustion and heat related activity. Aug 10, 2012 i note a whistling sound from the furnace.
Though these changes might be slight, repeated and continuous expansion and contraction may lead to. When the the cycle stops, i dont hear any hissing after which could mean water leaking out of the exchanger. Here is my scenariocan someone give me an opinion of my situation. The metal chambers of the heat exchanger prevent the combustion gases from mingling with the air that enters your house and which you. Miss a cracked heat exchanger and you put the homeowners at risk. The wintergreen test oil of wintergreen is sprayed into the combustion chamber with the blower operating, then see if the smell is present at the supply. To my knowledge there is no single check available that will find a crack in a heat exchanger 100% percent of the time and cracked heat exchangers result in less than 1 percent of carbon monoxide poisoning events. Mar 27, 2018 the heat exchanger in a gas furnace plays two roles. Ive used every pain in the ass method of hx inspection, but it seems to me that to keep time down on service calls a simple fan on off excess air reading will tell 100% if air from the blower is comminucating with air from inside the heat exchanger through cracks holes etc. Simply put, the furnace heat exchanger is the part of your furnace that actually heats the air. The chamber sits next to a heat exchanger, which transfers heat but not gases.
There are older, traditional ways for finding cracked heat exchangers, such as smoke bomb methods, which contractors have relied on for years. Bobs answer to whether or not a cracked heat exchanger can be dangerous is unambiguous. The only way to ensure your furnace is operating efficiently and safely is to hire a qualified furnace technician. Cracks in furnaces all about homes by john schnedier q. A cracked heat exchanger allows air from the furnace blower to interfere with the flame causing it to flutter or even roll out. Guide to furnace heat exchanger inspection, testing, leaks how to inspect and test furnace heat exchangers for leaks photographs show clues indicating leaky, dangerous furnace heat exchangers furnace heat exchanger leak testing, a complete list of methods used to find or test for leaks in a furnace heat exchange what is the allowable amount of gas fired heat exchanger. As air is circulated through the hvac system, it passes over the heat exchanger and absorbs thermal energy before its circulated throughout the house. With the majority of the cracked heat exchangers that ive seen, ive always been curious how the exhaust gas from the furnace could possibly leak out of those tiny cracks enough to contaminate the househouse air. Look for signs that the metal has been overheated, or symptoms of longterm metal fatigue. But if the passageway holding that heat exchanger is cracked or damaged, that condensation will find its way onto your floor. This can occur through heat transfer by means of convection, thermal conduction or thermal radiation. In a typical season, our nate certified furnace technicians confirm less than 10% of. One of the most common reasons a gas furnace can be taken out of service, is when the repair technician finds to a cracked heat exchanger.
As a homeowner, getting the news that your heat exchanger is cracked is a bit of a harsh blow. Unfortunately, for older furnaces, it can be more difficult to find a matching heat exchanger. This heating season, numerous dayton heating contractors are lying about cracked heat exchangers in an attempt to sell more furnaces. Contact details heat exchange water treatment and heat.
Many hvac contractors find cracked heat exchangers using visual analysis and use the results to recommend furnace replacement. Second, the entire furnace may need to be replaced. Thermal fatigue in hvac heat exchangers hvac investigators. In order to prepare for the winter, i had my forced air furnace serviced by a repairman. When the heat exchanger fails the air pressure and venting inside the combustion chamber changes. In years past, with older furnaces, a heat exchanger crack or small slit could turn into a big, gaping split once the heat exchanger warmed up. Before you can do any repairs, you should make sure that you check over your furnace heat exchanger thoroughly. Reverse the risk even after having a company manager provide a second. Click here to see a cracked gas furnace heat exchanger. Flame rollout via vent blockageheat exchanger hvac. Mar 11, 20 so lets get back to basics for a minute here and talk about what a heat exchanger is and what it does. A crack in the heat exchanger of the furnace is a dangerous situation. Because of this pressure, any hole or crack in the heat exchanger will allow air into the heat exhanger. Heat exchanger cracks and carbon monoxide myths by reuben saltzman in carbon monoxide alarms, cracked heat exchanger, hvac, new on december 2, 2014 i recently had a reader email this question.
Pour a little bit of the chemical on the hole, and leave it to dry until it seals around the exchanger. In this latest case, the contractor noticed there was a crack in the heat exchanger of the unit, requiring him by law to shut off the gas and electricity to the unit. Diagnosis of a heat exchanger crack typically starts with a noheat service call. Mar 05, 2014 then watch the flame and see if color changes from blue to a bright orange and if flame moves around. Cracks in your hvac heat exchanger may be due to the following. Unfortunately, a bad heat exchanger is a very expensive repair. Oct 05, 2012 i demonstrate how the gmp 050 to 100 model furnace heat exchanger failure diagnosis is done. This fall, the poor economy has pushed unethical contractors even further. A warning about cracked heat exchangers in gas furnace. It is a combination metal chamber and passageway that starts at the burner. The heat of the combustion gas raises the temperature of the metal, and as the air from the blower passes around it, heat transfers to it. Corrosion because of reaction between the combustion gas and the metal often because of improper venting can also weaken the metal to the point where cracks.
Should i replace my heat exchanger or buy a new furnace. A cracked heat exchanger is pretty serious, as far as safety for your home goes. In heat transfer, thermal energy is transferred from warmer areas to colder ones. In the video above the furnace techs says the oxygen reading could rise as high as 4050% if the heat exchanger is cracked. What are some tell tale signs of a cracked heat exchanger.
889 614 1322 989 347 715 1539 527 1267 584 683 922 350 1243 600 911 430 20 269 88 1112 970 131 896 333 555 742 1077 151 128 331 1065 231 958 441 1531 328 1330 362 57 1033 1244 1494 679 1321